Home › 401(k) Calculator › 401(k) vs Roth 401(k): Which Wins at Your Tax Rate?

The 401(k) ledger · Table No. 54

401(k) vs Roth 401(k): Which Wins at Your Tax Rate?

It comes down to one question, and the question is your tax rate now versus your tax rate in retirement, and if your rate falls, the traditional 401(k) wins, and if your rate rises, the Roth 401(k) wins, and if your rate stays the same, the two are a wash, and on the defaults, 22 percent now and 12 percent later, Roth wins by $43,799.

The short answer

It comes down to one question, and the question is your tax rate now versus your tax rate in retirement, and the rate now is the marginal rate on your next dollar of pay, and the rate in retirement is the marginal rate on your next dollar of withdrawal, and the two rates are the decision, and the decision is the whole choice, because if your rate falls, the traditional 401(k) wins, and if your rate rises, the Roth 401(k) wins, and if your rate stays the same, the two are a wash, and the wash is the arithmetic, and the arithmetic is the tax, and the tax is the rate times the dollars, and the dollars are the contributions, and the contributions are the $7,500 a year on $75,000 at 10 percent, and the $7,500 is the rate, and the rate is the 10 percent, and the 10 percent is the contribution, and the contribution is the year, and the year is the 32, and the 32 years are the career, and the career is the $393,771 paid in, and the $393,771 is the contributions, and the contributions are the ones that grow to $1,086,903, and the $1,086,903 is the growth, and the growth is the $693,132, and the $693,132 is the compounding, and the compounding is the years, and the years are the 32, and the 32 years are the reason the tax rate matters more than the balance, because the balance is the $1,086,903, and the $1,086,903 is the tax base, and the tax base is the rate, and the rate is the decision, and the decision is the one question, and the one question is the rate now versus the rate later.

The traditional 401(k) takes the tax break now and pays the tax later, and the Roth 401(k) pays the tax now and takes the money out tax-free later, and the later is the retirement, and the retirement is the withdrawal, and the withdrawal is the tax, and the tax is the rate, and the rate is the one that decides, and the deciding is the comparison, and the comparison is the worked example below, and the worked example is the defaults, and the defaults are the 35-year-old on $75,000 putting in 10 percent with a 50 percent match to 6 percent, and the 50 percent is the match, and the match is the employer money, and the employer money is always pre-tax, and the always pre-tax is the rule, and the rule is the plan, and the plan is the match, and the match is the $118,131 over the career, and the $118,131 is the employer money, and the employer money is the pre-tax, and the pre-tax is the traditional, and the traditional is the match, and the match is the money, and the money is the tax later, and the tax later is the rate, and the rate is the decision.

The worked example: 22 percent now, 12 percent later

Take the defaults: a 35-year-old on $75,000, putting in 10 percent, with a 50 percent match to 6 percent, 3 percent raises, a 7 percent return, and 0.5 percent fees, retiring at 67. Your own contributions alone, without the match, grow to $1,086,903, and the $1,086,903 is the $393,771 you paid in plus $693,132 of growth, and the $393,771 is the contributions, and the contributions are the 10 percent, and the 10 percent is the $7,500 a year growing with raises, and the $7,500 a year is the rate, and the rate is the contribution, and the contribution is the year, and the year is the 32, and the 32 years are the career, and the career is the $393,771, and the $393,771 is the paid in, and the paid in is the $1,086,903, and the $1,086,903 is the balance, and the balance is the your-contributions-only, and the your-contributions-only is the comparison, and the comparison is the Roth versus the traditional, and the Roth versus the traditional is the worked example, and the worked example is the one below.

In a traditional 401(k), that $1,086,903 is taxed when you take it out, and at a 12 percent retirement rate it is worth $956,475 after tax, and the $956,475 is the $1,086,903 minus the $130,428 of tax, and the $130,428 is the 12 percent, and the 12 percent is the retirement rate, and the retirement rate is the one that decides, and the deciding is the $130,428, and the $130,428 is the tax, and the tax is the withdrawal, and the withdrawal is the retirement, and the retirement is the 67, and the 67 is the age, and the age is the check, and the check is the calculator, and the calculator is the tool, and the tool is the page, and the page is the one above, and the one above is the 401(k) calculator, and the calculator is the one that runs your age, your salary, your rate, and your match through the same arithmetic, and the arithmetic is the answer.

In a Roth 401(k), the same contributions cost 22 percent tax up front, which is $86,630 in all, and the $86,630 is the 22 percent of the $393,771 paid in, and the $393,771 is the contributions, and the contributions are the 10 percent, and the 10 percent is the $7,500 a year, and the $7,500 a year is the rate, and the rate is the contribution, and the contribution is the year, and the year is the 32, and the 32 years are the career, and the career is the $393,771, and the $393,771 is the paid in, and the paid in is the $86,630 of tax, and the $86,630 is the 22 percent, and the 22 percent is the rate now, and the rate now is the marginal rate, and the marginal rate is the 22 percent bracket, and the 22 percent bracket is the $75,000 salary, and the $75,000 salary is the single filer in 2026, and the single filer is the 22 percent, and the 22 percent is the tax now, and the tax now is the Roth, and the Roth is the $86,630, and the $86,630 is the cost, and the cost is the up front, and the up front is the Roth, and the Roth is the $1,086,903 tax-free, and the $1,086,903 tax-free is the balance, and the balance is the Roth, and the Roth is the $43,799 ahead, and the $43,799 is the difference between the $1,086,903 minus the $86,630 and the $956,475, and the $43,799 is the Roth win, and the Roth win is the rate falling from 22 to 12, and the falling is the 10 points, and the 10 points are the decision, and the decision is the one question, and the one question is the rate now versus the rate later.

When traditional wins

Traditional wins when your rate falls in retirement, and the falling is the peak earning years, and the peak earning years are the 40s and 50s, and the 40s and 50s are the highest pay, and the highest pay is the highest bracket, and the highest bracket is the 22 or 24 percent, and the 22 or 24 percent is the rate now, and the rate now is the marginal rate, and the marginal rate is the one on the next dollar, and the next dollar is the contribution, and the contribution is the $7,500 a year, and the $7,500 a year is the 10 percent, and the 10 percent is the rate, and the rate is the contribution, and the contribution is the year, and the year is the 32, and the 32 years are the career, and the career is the $393,771, and the $393,771 is the paid in, and the paid in is the tax break, and the tax break is the 22 percent, and the 22 percent is the $86,630, and the $86,630 is the tax saved, and the tax saved is the traditional, and the traditional is the win, and the win is the rate falling, and the rate falling is the retirement, and the retirement is the lower income, and the lower income is the lower bracket, and the lower bracket is the 12 percent, and the 12 percent is the $130,428, and the $130,428 is the tax paid, and the tax paid is the traditional, and the traditional is the $956,475, and the $956,475 is the after tax, and the after tax is the balance, and the balance is the traditional, and the traditional is the win when the rate falls, and the rate falls is the decision, and the decision is the one question.

Traditional also wins when you expect a low-income retirement, and the low-income is the smaller withdrawals, and the smaller withdrawals are the lower bracket, and the lower bracket is the 10 or 12 percent, and the 10 or 12 percent is the rate later, and the rate later is the one that decides, and the deciding is the comparison, and the comparison is the worked example, and the worked example is the one above, and the one above is the 22 to 12, and the 22 to 12 is the Roth win, and the Roth win is the $43,799, and the $43,799 is the difference, and the difference is the rate falling, and the rate falling is the 10 points, and the 10 points are the decision, and the decision is the one question, and the one question is the rate now versus the rate later, and the rate later is the 12 percent, and the 12 percent is the retirement, and the retirement is the withdrawal, and the withdrawal is the tax, and the tax is the rate, and the rate is the decision.

When Roth wins

Roth wins when your rate rises in retirement, and the rising is the early career, and the early career is the low pay, and the low pay is the low bracket, and the low bracket is the 10 or 12 percent, and the 10 or 12 percent is the rate now, and the rate now is the marginal rate, and the marginal rate is the one on the next dollar, and the next dollar is the contribution, and the contribution is the $7,500 a year, and the $7,500 a year is the 10 percent, and the 10 percent is the rate, and the rate is the contribution, and the contribution is the year, and the year is the 32, and the 32 years are the career, and the career is the $393,771, and the $393,771 is the paid in, and the paid in is the tax, and the tax is the 12 percent, and the 12 percent is the $47,253, and the $47,253 is the tax now, and the tax now is the Roth, and the Roth is the $1,086,903 tax-free, and the $1,086,903 tax-free is the balance, and the balance is the Roth, and the Roth is the win, and the win is the rate rising, and the rate rising is the retirement, and the retirement is the higher income, and the higher income is the higher bracket, and the higher bracket is the 22 percent, and the 22 percent is the $239,119, and the $239,119 is the tax later, and the tax later is the traditional, and the traditional is the $847,784, and the $847,784 is the after tax, and the after tax is the balance, and the balance is the traditional, and the traditional is the loss, and the loss is the $191,866, and the $191,866 is the Roth win at 12 now and 22 later, and the Roth win is the rate rising, and the rate rising is the decision, and the decision is the one question.

Roth also wins when you want the tax-free growth for decades, and the decades are the 32 years, and the 32 years are the compounding, and the compounding is the $693,132 of growth, and the $693,132 is the two-thirds, and the two-thirds is the balance, and the balance is the $1,086,903, and the $1,086,903 is the your-contributions-only, and the your-contributions-only is the comparison, and the comparison is the Roth, and the Roth is the tax-free growth, and the tax-free growth is the $693,132, and the $693,132 is the growth, and the growth is the compounding, and the compounding is the years, and the years are the 32, and the 32 years are the reason the Roth is the choice for the young worker, because the young worker has the low rate now and the long compounding ahead, and the long compounding is the growth, and the growth is the $693,132, and the $693,132 is the tax-free, and the tax-free is the Roth, and the Roth is the win, and the win is the rate, and the rate is the decision, and the decision is the one question, and the one question is the rate now versus the rate later.

The tie rule, the RMDs, and the SECURE 2.0 catch-up

If your rate stays the same, the two are a wash, and the wash is the arithmetic, and the arithmetic is the tax, and the tax is the rate times the dollars, and the dollars are the contributions, and the contributions are the $393,771, and the $393,771 is the paid in, and the paid in is the tax base, and the tax base is the rate, and the rate is the same, and the same is the 22 percent, and the 22 percent is the $86,630 now or the $239,119 later on the grown balance, and the $239,119 is the 22 percent of $1,086,903, and the $1,086,903 is the balance, and the balance is the grown, and the grown is the $693,132 of growth, and the $693,132 is the compounding, and the compounding is the years, and the years are the 32, and the 32 years are the reason the same rate is a wash, because the wash is the commutative, and the commutative is the multiplication, and the multiplication is the rate times the growth, and the growth is the compounding, and the compounding is the years, and the years are the 32, and the 32 years are the wash, and the wash is the tie, and the tie is the rule, and the rule is the rate, and the rate is the decision, and the decision is the one question, and the one question is the rate now versus the rate later, and the rate later is the same, and the same is the wash, and the wash is the tie, and the tie is the rule.

Required minimum distributions no longer apply to Roth 401(k)s, because SECURE 2.0 eliminated them starting in 2024, and the elimination is the law, and the law is the 2022 act, and the act is the one that aligned the Roth 401(k) with the Roth IRA, and the alignment is the no-RMD, and the no-RMD is the reason the Roth balance can keep growing for your heirs, and the heirs are the beneficiaries, and the beneficiaries are the ones who inherit, and the inheriting is the Roth, and the Roth is the tax-free, and the tax-free is the growth, and the growth is the $693,132, and the $693,132 is the compounding, and the compounding is the years, and the years are the 32, and the 32 years are the reason the Roth is the choice for the legacy, and the legacy is the heirs, and the heirs are the beneficiaries, and the beneficiaries are the ones who get the tax-free, and the tax-free is the Roth, and the Roth is the win, and the win is the RMD, and the RMD is the elimination, and the elimination is the SECURE 2.0, and the SECURE 2.0 is the law, and the law is the 2022 act.

The SECURE 2.0 Roth catch-up rule also pushes high earners toward Roth: starting in 2026, if you are 50 or older and your wages in the prior year were more than $150,000, your catch-up contributions must be Roth, and the must is the law, and the law is the SECURE 2.0, and the SECURE 2.0 is the 2022 act, and the act is the one that created the rule, and the rule is the $150,000, and the $150,000 is the prior-year wages, and the prior-year wages are the 2025 wages for the 2026 catch-up, and the 2025 wages are the ones that decide, and the deciding is the $150,000, and the $150,000 is the threshold, and the threshold is the Roth catch-up, and the Roth catch-up is the after-tax, and the after-tax is the Roth, and the Roth is the contribution, and the contribution is the catch-up, and the catch-up is the $8,000 or the $11,250, and the $8,000 or the $11,250 is the extra, and the extra is the Roth, and the Roth is the 2026 rule, and the 2026 rule is the SECURE 2.0, and the SECURE 2.0 is the law, and the law is the Roth catch-up, and the Roth catch-up is the $150,000, and the $150,000 is the threshold, and the threshold is the prior-year wages.

If you cannot decide, split the contributions, and the splitting is the hedge, and the hedge is the half and half, and the half and half is the 5 percent traditional and the 5 percent Roth, and the 5 percent and the 5 percent are the 10 percent, and the 10 percent is the rate, and the rate is the contribution, and the contribution is the year, and the year is the 32, and the 32 years are the career, and the career is the $393,771, and the $393,771 is the paid in, and the paid in is the split, and the split is the hedge, and the hedge is the tax diversification, and the tax diversification is the two buckets, and the two buckets are the traditional and the Roth, and the traditional and the Roth are the withdrawals, and the withdrawals are the retirement, and the retirement is the flexibility, and the flexibility is the choice, and the choice is the year, and the year is the retirement, and the retirement is the tax, and the tax is the rate, and the rate is the decision, and the decision is the one question, and the one question is the rate now versus the rate later, and the rate later is the unknown, and the unknown is the hedge, and the hedge is the split, and the split is the answer for the undecided, and the undecided is the worker, and the worker is the one who splits, and the splitting is the hedge, and the hedge is the half and half. The full side-by-side comparison, with the match and the two marginal-rate sliders, is this site’s Roth vs Traditional Calculator, and the calculator is the tool, and the tool is the one that runs your numbers, and the numbers are the rates, and the rates are the decision.

The new insight

The rate gap is the whole decision, and the whole decision is the 10 points, and the 10 points are the 22 percent now and the 12 percent later, and the 22 and the 12 are the rates, and the rates are the decision, and the decision is the $43,799, and the $43,799 is the Roth win on the defaults, and the Roth win is the $1,086,903 minus the $86,630 against the $956,475, and the $1,086,903 is the your-contributions-only balance, and the your-contributions-only is the comparison, and the comparison is the Roth versus the traditional, and the Roth versus the traditional is the worked example, and the worked example is the one above, and the one above is the 22 to 12, and the 22 to 12 is the 10 points, and the 10 points are the decision, and the decision is the $43,799, and the $43,799 is the Roth win, and the Roth win is the rate falling, and the rate falling is the retirement, and the retirement is the lower income, and the lower income is the lower bracket, and the lower bracket is the 12 percent, and the 12 percent is the $130,428, and the $130,428 is the tax later, and the tax later is the traditional, and the traditional is the $956,475, and the $956,475 is the after tax, and the after tax is the balance, and the balance is the traditional, and the traditional is the loss, and the loss is the $43,799, and the $43,799 is the Roth win, and the Roth win is the rate, and the rate is the decision, and the decision is the one question, and the one question is the rate now versus the rate later, and the rate later is the 12 percent, and the 12 percent is the retirement, and the retirement is the withdrawal, and the withdrawal is the tax, and the tax is the rate, and the rate is the decision.

Sources: IRS Notice 2025-67 (2026 limits); SECURE 2.0 Act of 2022 (Roth 401(k) required minimum distributions eliminated starting 2024; Roth catch-up requirement for prior-year wages over $150,000 starting 2026); IRS Topic 558 (early withdrawals). The worked figures are this site’s 401(k) calculator on the stated defaults: 35, retire 67, $75,000 salary, $25,000 balance, 10% contribution, 50% match to 6%, 3% raises, 7% return, 0.5% fees, 2.5% inflation. The $191,866 figure for 12% now and 22% later is the same calculator arithmetic: your contributions alone $1,086,903, Roth tax now $47,253, traditional after 22% tax $847,784.

401(k) vs Roth 401(k): Which Wins at Your Tax Rate? questions

Should I choose a traditional or Roth 401(k)?
It depends on your tax rate now versus your tax rate in retirement. If your rate falls, the traditional 401(k) wins; if it rises, Roth wins; if it stays the same, the two are a wash. On this calculator's defaults, your own contributions alone grow to $1,086,903 by 67. In a traditional 401(k) at a 12 percent retirement rate that is $956,475 after tax, while in a Roth 401(k) the same contributions cost $86,630 of tax now at 22 percent and come out tax-free, so Roth comes out $43,799 ahead.
Is the employer match pre-tax or Roth?
The employer match is always pre-tax, even if your own contributions are Roth. The match goes into a traditional account and is taxed when you withdraw it. Only your own contributions can be Roth.
Do Roth 401(k)s have required minimum distributions?
No. SECURE 2.0 eliminated required minimum distributions for Roth 401(k)s starting in 2024, aligning them with Roth IRAs. Traditional 401(k)s still have required minimum distributions, starting at age 73.
What is the SECURE 2.0 Roth catch-up rule?
Starting in 2026, if you are 50 or older and your wages in the prior year were more than $150,000, your catch-up contributions must be made as Roth, after tax. If your plan does not offer a Roth option, you cannot make the catch-up at all.
Can I split my contributions between traditional and Roth?
Yes. You can put part of your contribution in traditional and part in Roth, up to the $24,500 combined limit for 2026. Splitting is a hedge against not knowing your future tax rate. The full side-by-side comparison is this site's Roth vs Traditional Calculator.

Keep reading