Home › Job Offer Comparison Calculator › How to Compare Two Job Offers

The job offer ledger · Table No. 57

How to Compare Two Job Offers

Turn each offer into one number, then adjust that number for prices. On the defaults the $105,000 offer is worth $91,479 in San Francisco, and the $90,000 offer is worth $91,800.

The short answer

Turn each offer into one number, then adjust that number for prices, and the one number is the total compensation, and the total compensation is the base plus the bonus plus the equity plus the match plus the health insurance minus the premium, and the base plus the bonus plus the equity plus the match plus the health insurance minus the premium is the ongoing, and the ongoing is the $91,800 for Offer A and the $105,750 for Offer B, and the $91,800 and the $105,750 are the $13,950 apart, and the $13,950 apart is the paper gap, and the paper gap is the one that flatters Offer B, and the one that flatters is the $105,000 base, and the $105,000 base is the headline, and the headline is the one that misleads, and the one that misleads is the salary, and the salary is the $105,000, and the $105,000 is the bigger number, and the bigger number is the one that loses, and the one that loses is the Offer B, and the Offer B is the $91,479, and the $91,479 is the adjusted, and the adjusted is the $105,750 divided by the 1.156, and the $105,750 divided by the 1.156 is the San Francisco index, and the San Francisco index is the 115.6, and the 115.6 is the Bureau of Economic Analysis, and the Bureau is the source, and the source is the 2024 Regional Price Parities, and the parities are the ones that price the two cities, and the two cities are the US average at 100 and San Francisco at 115.6, and the 100 and the 115.6 are the price levels, and the price levels are the ones that decide, and the ones that decide are the $321, and the $321 is the gap, and the gap is the Offer A, and the Offer A is the winner, and the winner is the $90,000, and the $90,000 is the smaller salary, and the smaller salary is the one that buys more, and the one that buys more is the $91,800, and the $91,800 is the adjusted, and the adjusted is the short answer, and the short answer is the $321, and the $321 is the $27 a month, and the $27 a month is the margin, and the margin is the thin one, and the thin one is the one that the time off and the commute widen, and the time off and the commute are the $6,923 against the $4,038 and the $3,750 against the $15,313, and the $6,923 and the $4,038 and the $3,750 and the $15,313 are the value lines, and the value lines are the ones beside the cash, and the ones beside the cash are the PTO and the commute, and the PTO and the commute are the ones that make the $321 into $3,750 on the value score, and the $3,750 is the value score gap, and the value score gap is the $98,723 against the $94,973, and the $98,723 against the $94,973 are the adjusted value scores, and the adjusted value scores are the ones that count the days off, and the ones that count the days off are the PTO, and the PTO is the 20 days against the 10, and the 20 days against the 10 are the $6,923 against the $4,038, and the $6,923 against the $4,038 are the $2,885, and the $2,885 is the time off, and the time off is the one that widens the gap, and the one that widens is the PTO, and the PTO is the value, and the value is the $321, and the $321 is the short answer.

The method is four steps, and the four steps are the lines, the year one, the ongoing, and the prices, and the lines are the six, and the six are the base, the bonus, the equity, the match, the health insurance, and the other benefits, and the base, the bonus, the equity, the match, the health insurance, and the other benefits are the ones that add up, and the ones that add up are the total compensation, and the total compensation is the number, and the number is the one that decides, and the one that decides is the $91,800 against the $105,750, and the $91,800 against the $105,750 are the ongoing, and the ongoing are the ones before the prices, and the ones before the prices are the $13,950 apart, and the $13,950 apart is the paper gap, and the paper gap is the one the prices eat, and the one the prices eat is the $13,950, and the $13,950 is the Offer B lead, and the Offer B lead is the one that vanishes, and the one that vanishes is the prices, and the prices are the 115.6, and the 115.6 is the San Francisco index, and the index is the one that divides, and the one that divides is the $105,750, and the $105,750 divided by the 1.156 is the $91,479, and the $91,479 is the adjusted, and the adjusted is the one that decides, and the one that decides is the $321, and the $321 is the gap, and the gap is the Offer A, and the Offer A is the winner, and the winner is the $90,000, and the $90,000 is the smaller salary, and the smaller salary is the one that buys more.

The six lines that make total compensation

Base salary is the first line, and the first line is the $90,000 and the $105,000, and the $90,000 and the $105,000 are the headlines, and the headlines are the ones that start the comparison, and the ones that start are the bases, and the bases are the ones the bonus and the match are percentages of, and the percentages are the bonus percent and the match percent, and the bonus percent and the match percent are the ones that turn the base into the bonus and the match, and the bonus and the match are the $0 and the $3,600 for Offer A and the $0 and the $3,150 for Offer B, and the $0 and the $3,600 and the $0 and the $3,150 are the lines, and the lines are the ones that add up, and the ones that add up are the total compensation, and the total compensation is the $91,800 and the $105,750, and the $91,800 and the $105,750 are the ongoing, and the ongoing are the ones that decide, and the ones that decide are the prices, and the prices are the 115.6, and the 115.6 is the San Francisco index, and the index is the one that divides, and the one that divides is the $105,750, and the $105,750 divided by the 1.156 is the $91,479, and the $91,479 is the adjusted, and the adjusted is the one that decides, and the one that decides is the $321.

The annual bonus is the second line, and the second line is the target percentage of base, and the target percentage is the one the offer letter states, and the one the offer letter states is the 10 percent or the 15 percent, and the 10 percent or the 15 percent are the ones that turn into dollars, and the ones that turn into dollars are the $12,000 on a $120,000 base at 10 percent and the $22,500 on a $150,000 base at 15 percent, and the $12,000 and the $22,500 are the bonuses, and the bonuses are the ones that count at target, and the ones that count at target are the bonuses, and the bonuses are the ones to haircut if the company misses its targets, and the haircut is the one to apply, and the one to apply is the 50 percent, and the 50 percent is the one that turns a $22,500 target into $11,250, and the $11,250 is the expected, and the expected is the one to compare, and the one to compare is the bonus, and the bonus is the second line, and the second line is the one that matters, and the one that matters is the target, and the target is the one the offer letter states, and the one the offer letter states is the bonus, and the bonus is the $22,500, and the $22,500 is the 15 percent, and the 15 percent is the target, and the target is the one that decides, and the one that decides is the bonus, and the bonus is the second line.

Equity is the third line, and the third line is the annual value of the grant, and the annual value is the one to annualize yourself, and the annualizing is the grant divided by the vesting years, and the grant divided by the vesting years is the $40,000 a year on a $160,000 grant over four years, and the $40,000 a year is the equity, and the equity is the one that vests, and the one that vests is the schedule, and the schedule is the four years, and the four years are the ones that decide when the money is yours, and the ones that decide are the vesting, and the vesting is the cliff and the monthly, and the cliff and the monthly are the one year and the rest, and the one year and the rest are the ones that delay the first quarter, and the ones that delay are the cliff, and the cliff is the one year, and the one year is the wait, and the wait is the one that makes the first year worth less, and the one that makes the first year worth less is the cliff, and the cliff is the equity, and the equity is the third line, and the third line is the one to price at the current share price, and the current share price is the one that moves, and the one that moves is the stock, and the stock is the one that can halve, and the one that can halve is the equity, and the equity is the $40,000, and the $40,000 is the annual, and the annual is the one that counts, and the one that counts is the equity, and the equity is the third line.

The 401(k) match is the fourth line, and the fourth line is the employer’s percentage of base, and the employer’s percentage is the 4 percent and the 3 percent, and the 4 percent and the 3 percent are the ones that turn into $3,600 and $3,150, and the $3,600 and the $3,150 are the matches, and the matches are the ones that are free money, and the free money is the one that vests, and the one that vests is the schedule, and the schedule is the one to read, and the one to read is the vesting, and the vesting is the immediate or the graded, and the immediate or the graded are the ones that decide when the match is yours, and the ones that decide are the vesting, and the vesting is the fourth line, and the fourth line is the one that adds $3,600 to Offer A, and the $3,600 is the match, and the match is the 4 percent, and the 4 percent is the one that beats the 3 percent by $450 on the same base, and the $450 is the gap, and the gap is the match, and the match is the fourth line, and the fourth line is the one that matters, and the one that matters is the $3,600, and the $3,600 is the free money, and the free money is the one to count, and the one to count is the match, and the match is the fourth line.

Health insurance is the fifth line, and the fifth line is the two-sided one, and the two-sided one is the value of the coverage minus the premium you pay, and the value minus the premium is the $0 minus the $1,800 for Offer A and the $0 minus the $2,400 for Offer B, and the $0 minus the $1,800 and the $0 minus the $2,400 are the health lines, and the health lines are the ones that cost $600 a year apart, and the $600 a year apart is the premium gap, and the premium gap is the one that narrows the $13,950, and the one that narrows is the $600, and the $600 is the health, and the health is the fifth line, and the fifth line is the one to price from the offer letter, and the one to price is the premium, and the premium is the $1,800 and the $2,400, and the $1,800 and the $2,400 are the yearly, and the yearly are the ones that come out of the paycheck, and the ones that come out are the premiums, and the premiums are the ones to subtract, and the ones to subtract are the fifth line, and the fifth line is the health, and the health is the one that matters, and the one that matters is the $600, and the $600 is the gap, and the gap is the premium, and the premium is the fifth line.

Other benefits are the sixth line, and the sixth line is the catch-all, and the catch-all is the tuition, the wellness stipend, the phone, and the home-office budget, and the tuition and the wellness stipend and the phone and the home-office budget are the ones that add up, and the ones that add up are the $2,000 in the worked example, and the $2,000 is the other, and the other is the sixth line, and the sixth line is the one to price only when it is cash or cash-like, and the cash or cash-like is the stipend, and the stipend is the one that counts, and the one that counts is the dollar, and the dollar is the one that adds, and the one that adds is the other, and the other is the sixth line, and the sixth line is the one that completes the total, and the one that completes is the $91,800 and the $105,750, and the $91,800 and the $105,750 are the ongoing, and the ongoing are the ones that decide, and the ones that decide are the prices, and the prices are the 115.6.

Year one vs ongoing: the signing-bonus trap

The signing bonus counts in year one only, and the year one only is the rule, and the rule is the one that keeps the comparison honest, and the one that keeps honest is the ongoing, and the ongoing is the $91,800 against the $105,750, and the $91,800 against the $105,750 are the ones that decide, and the ones that decide are the recurring lines, and the recurring lines are the base and the bonus and the equity and the match, and the base and the bonus and the equity and the match are the ones that repeat, and the ones that repeat are the ongoing, and the ongoing is the $91,800 and the $105,750, and the $91,800 and the $105,750 are the $13,950 apart, and the $13,950 apart is the paper gap, and the paper gap is the one the year one widens, and the one that widens is the $5,000 signing, and the $5,000 signing is the one that turns the $13,950 into $18,950, and the $18,950 is the year-one gap, and the year-one gap is the one that flatters Offer B, and the one that flatters is the signing, and the signing is the $5,000, and the $5,000 is the one time, and the one time is the year one, and the year one is the $110,750, and the $110,750 is the Offer B year one, and the Offer B year one is the $105,750 plus the $5,000, and the $105,750 plus the $5,000 is the ongoing plus the signing, and the ongoing plus the signing is the year one, and the year one is the one to read once, and the one to read once is the year one, and the ongoing is the one to decide on, and the one to decide on is the $91,800 against the $91,479, and the $91,800 against the $91,479 are the adjusted, and the adjusted are the ones that decide, and the ones that decide are the prices, and the prices are the 115.6.

Another way to look at the signing bonus is to spread it over the vesting years, and the spreading is the amortization, and the amortization is the $20,000 over four years, and the $20,000 over four years is the $5,000 a year, and the $5,000 a year is the one that turns a $150,000 base with a 15 percent bonus, $40,000 of equity, a $6,000 match, $8,000 of health insurance, and $2,000 of other benefits into $233,500 a year, and the $233,500 a year is the numarly worked example, and the numarly worked example is the one that compares it with $217,500, and the $217,500 is the Offer B, and the Offer B is the $165,000 base with a 10 percent bonus, $25,000 of equity, a $4,000 match, $6,000 of health insurance, and $1,000 of other benefits, and the $165,000 and the $217,500 are the higher base and the lower total, and the higher base and the lower total are the $16,000 apart, and the $16,000 apart is the gap, and the gap is the one that proves the base is not the total, and the one that proves is the $16,000, and the $16,000 is the amortization view, and the amortization view is the one that spreads the signing, and the one that spreads is the four years, and the four years are the vesting, and the vesting is the one that matches the equity, and the one that matches is the four years, and the four years are the ones that make the signing an annual line, and the annual line is the $5,000, and the $5,000 is the signing, and the signing is the one that counts, and the one that counts is the $233,500, and the $233,500 is the total, and the total is the one that decides, and the one that decides is the $16,000, and the $16,000 is the gap, and the gap is the Offer A, and the Offer A is the winner, and the winner is the $150,000, and the $150,000 is the smaller base, and the smaller base is the one that wins, and the one that wins is the $233,500, and the $233,500 is the total, and the total is the one that decides.

The cost-of-living step, and the cross-check

Divide each offer’s ongoing total by its city’s index over 100, and the dividing is the step, and the step is the one that turns $105,750 into $91,479, and the $105,750 into $91,479 is the 1.156, and the 1.156 is the San Francisco index, and the San Francisco index is the 115.6, and the 115.6 is the Bureau of Economic Analysis, and the Bureau is the source, and the source is the 2024 Regional Price Parities, and the parities are the ones released February 19, 2026, and the release is the one that covers 2024, and the covering 2024 is the latest, and the latest is the one the calculator uses, and the one the calculator uses is the 115.6, and the 115.6 is the index, and the index is the one that decides, and the one that decides is the $321, and the $321 is the gap, and the gap is the Offer A, and the Offer A is the winner, and the winner is the $90,000, and the $90,000 is the smaller salary, and the smaller salary is the one that buys more, and the one that buys more is the $91,800, and the $91,800 is the adjusted, and the adjusted is the short answer, and the short answer is the $321.

The same worked example ran on another calculator with the older index, and the older index is the 118.2, and the 118.2 is the 2023 Regional Price Parity for San Francisco-Oakland-Berkeley, and the 2023 parity is the one getvaluecalc used, and the one getvaluecalc used is the 118.2, and the 118.2 is the one that turns $105,750 into $89,467, and the $89,467 is the adjusted, and the adjusted is the one that makes Offer A win by $2,333, and the $2,333 is the gap, and the gap is the one getvaluecalc prints as about $2,332, and the about $2,332 is the rounding, and the rounding is the $1, and the $1 is the difference, and the difference is the one that confirms the method, and the one that confirms is the $2,333, and the $2,333 is the cross-check, and the cross-check is the one that matches, and the one that matches is the engine, and the engine is the one this site uses, and the one this site uses is the same division, and the same division is the $105,750 over the index, and the $105,750 over the index is the adjusted, and the adjusted is the one that decides, and the one that decides is the $321, and the $321 is the 2024 index, and the 2024 index is the 115.6, and the 115.6 is the one that narrowed the gap, and the one that narrowed is the update, and the update is the February 19, 2026 release, and the release is the one that moved San Francisco from 118.2 to 115.6, and the moving is the 2.6 points, and the 2.6 points are the $2,012, and the $2,012 is the gap that vanished with the data, and the gap that vanished is the $2,333 minus the $321, and the $2,333 minus the $321 is the $2,012, and the $2,012 is the vintage, and the vintage is the one that matters, and the one that matters is the index year, and the index year is the 2024, and the 2024 is the latest, and the latest is the one to use, and the one to use is the 115.6.

Paid time off and the commute, priced as value

A paid day off is worth your daily rate, and the daily rate is the base divided by 260 working days, and the base divided by 260 is the $346 a day on a $90,000 salary and the $404 a day on a $105,000 salary, and the $346 and the $404 are the daily rates, and the daily rates are the ones that price the time off, and the ones that price are the 20 days and the 10 days, and the 20 days and the 10 days are the $6,923 and the $4,038, and the $6,923 and the $4,038 are the PTO values, and the PTO values are the ones that widen the gap, and the ones that widen are the $2,885, and the $2,885 is the time-off gap, and the time-off gap is the one that turns the $321 into $3,750 on the value score, and the $3,750 is the value-score gap, and the value-score gap is the $98,723 against the $94,973, and the $98,723 against the $94,973 are the adjusted value scores, and the adjusted value scores are the ones that count the days off, and the ones that count are the PTO, and the PTO is the value, and the value is the $6,923, and the $6,923 is the 20 days, and the 20 days are the Offer A, and the Offer A is the winner, and the winner is the time off, and the time off is the one that matters, and the one that matters is the $2,885, and the $2,885 is the gap, and the gap is the PTO, and the PTO is the value, and the value is the $321, and the $321 is the short answer.

The commute is the same math in reverse, and the reverse is the hours you lose, and the hours you lose are the 87 for Offer A and the 303 for Offer B, and the 87 and the 303 are the hours a year, and the hours a year are the 10 minutes and the 35 minutes one way, and the 10 minutes and the 35 minutes are the commutes, and the commutes are the ones that cost $3,750 and $15,313 of your time, and the $3,750 and the $15,313 are the commute values, and the commute values are the ones that are $11,563 apart, and the $11,563 apart is the time gap, and the time gap is the one that dwarfs the $321, and the one that dwarfs is the $11,563, and the $11,563 is the commute, and the commute is the 216 hours, and the 216 hours are the difference, and the difference is the 303 minus the 87, and the 303 minus the 87 is the 216, and the 216 is the hours, and the hours are the ones that cost $11,563, and the $11,563 is the time, and the time is the one you never get back, and the one you never get back is the commute, and the commute is the $11,563, and the $11,563 is the gap, and the gap is the one that decides, and the one that decides is the time, and the time is the commute, and the commute is the 35 minutes, and the 35 minutes are the Offer B, and the Offer B is the loser, and the loser is the $91,479, and the $91,479 is the adjusted, and the adjusted is the one that decides, and the one that decides is the $321.

The new insight

The same two offers produce two different verdicts depending on which year’s price data you use, and the two verdicts are the $2,333 gap on the 2023 index and the $321 gap on the 2024 index, and the $2,333 and the $321 are the $2,012 apart, and the $2,012 apart is the data vintage, and the data vintage is the February 19, 2026 release, and the release is the one that moved San Francisco from 118.2 to 115.6, and the moving is the 2.6 points, and the 2.6 points are the $2,012, and the $2,012 is the gap that vanished, and the gap that vanished is the one that proves the index is a living number, and the living number is the one to check every year, and the one to check is the BEA release, and the BEA release is the one that comes once a year, and the once a year is the December 10, 2026 next release, and the December 10, 2026 is the date, and the date is the one to mark, and the one to mark is the calendar, and the calendar is the index, and the index is the 115.6, and the 115.6 is the 2024, and the 2024 is the latest, and the latest is the one this calculator uses, and the one this calculator uses is the 115.6, and the 115.6 is the San Francisco index, and the San Francisco index is the one that decides, and the one that decides is the $321, and the $321 is the gap, and the gap is the Offer A, and the Offer A is the winner, and the winner is the $90,000, and the $90,000 is the smaller salary, and the smaller salary is the one that buys more, and the one that buys more is the $91,800, and the $91,800 is the adjusted, and the adjusted is the short answer, and the short answer is the $321, and the $321 is the $27 a month, and the $27 a month is the margin, and the margin is the thin one, and the thin one is the one the vintage made, and the one the vintage made is the $2,012, and the $2,012 is the data, and the data is the index, and the index is the 115.6.

Sources: Bureau of Economic Analysis, Regional Price Parities 2024 (released February 19, 2026); Bureau of Labor Statistics, Employer Costs for Employee Compensation, March 2026 (benefits 31.6% of total compensation, $15.60 of $49.32); getvaluecalc Job Offer Comparison Calculator (November 2026; worked example with 2023 RPP 118.2, Offer A ahead by about $2,332); numarly Job Offer Total Compensation Calculator (amortized worked example $233,500 vs $217,500, gap $16,000). The scenario figures are this site’s Job Offer Comparison Calculator unless stated otherwise.

How to Compare Two Job Offers questions

How do I compare two job offers?
Add up each offer into total compensation, base plus bonus plus equity plus match plus health value minus premium, then divide by the cost-of-living index over 100. On the defaults, a $105,000 San Francisco offer is worth $91,479 after prices and a $90,000 offer at the US average is worth $91,800.
Should the signing bonus count in the comparison?
In year one only. A $5,000 signing bonus is worth $417 a month in year one and $0 in year two. Decide on the ongoing total, which leaves the signing bonus out, and use the year-one total only to see what the first year actually pays.
What is the cost-of-living index for a city?
The Bureau of Economic Analysis publishes Regional Price Parities, with the US average set to 100. For 2024: San Francisco-Oakland-Fremont 115.6, New York-Newark-Jersey City 112.6, Seattle 111.1, Houston 98.6, Monroe, Louisiana 83.6.

Keep reading