Home › Tax Refund Estimator › Why Is My Tax Refund Smaller This Year?

The refund ledger · Table No. 58

Why Is My Tax Refund Smaller This Year?

A smaller refund usually means your withholding got more accurate, not that your taxes went up. The 2025 bump is unwinding, and three other reasons explain the rest.

The short answer

A smaller refund usually means your withholding got more accurate, not that your taxes went up. The most common reason in 2026 is the withholding tables. The One Big Beautiful Bill Act cut 2025 taxes, but the IRS did not update employer withholding tables for the rest of 2025, so paychecks kept withholding at the old, higher rates and 2026 refunds came in fat. The 2026 tables are updated. The same paycheck withholds less now, and the refund shrinks by the same amount. The tax did not rise. The loan to the IRS got smaller.

There are three other usual reasons: your income rose into a higher bracket, a credit disappeared, or your withholding changed. This article runs each one with numbers, so you can tell which one is yours.

The 2025 bump is unwinding

Start with the law. The One Big Beautiful Bill Act, signed July 4, 2025, added four new above-the-line deductions for tax years 2025 through 2028: tip income up to $25,000, overtime pay up to $12,500 for single filers and $25,000 for joint filers, a $6,000 deduction for filers 65 and older, and auto loan interest up to $10,000. It raised the Child Tax Credit to $2,200 and lifted the state-and-local-tax deduction cap to $40,000. The Tax Foundation estimates the law cut individual income taxes for 2025 by roughly $129 billion.

None of that reached paychecks in 2025. The IRS chose not to update employer withholding tables after the law passed, and CNBC reported the decision in January 2026. Employers kept withholding federal taxes at the old rates for all of 2025, even though workers owed less under the new law. The over-withholding showed up as refunds in the 2026 filing season. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said 44 percent of all returns filed, roughly 37.5 million, claimed at least one benefit from the law. The average refund peaked at $3,742 in the week ending February 20 and stood at $3,521 as of March 27, about $350 higher than the same point the year before.

For 2026, the tables are updated. The same paycheck withholds less, because the tax it is withholding against is lower. A filer whose 2025 refund was inflated by $350 of over-withholding will see a 2026 refund about $350 smaller, with the same income and the same credits. That is not a tax increase. It is the timing moving back to normal. The White House had projected an average increase of $1,000 or more for the 2026 season, citing early research from Piper Sandler. The actual increase hovered around $350, and the 2026 tables mean it will not repeat.

Your income rose

The second reason is the simplest. A raise increases the tax owed faster than it increases the refund, because withholding lags the raise and the brackets are marginal. Take a single filer at $65,000 with no pre-tax deductions and $6,500 withheld. The tax is $5,620 and the refund is $880. Give that filer a raise to $75,000 with the same $6,500 withheld. The tax becomes $7,670: $1,240 at 10 percent, $4,560 at 12 percent, and $1,870 at 22 percent on the $8,500 above $50,400. The refund becomes a balance due of $1,170. The raise was $10,000. The refund fell by $2,050, which is exactly the extra tax on the raise. The filer is $7,950 better off after tax and still feels poorer, because the refund vanished.

The fix is to compare the tax owed year over year, not the refund. The refund is the withholding minus the tax. The tax is the number that tells you whether you paid more. If the tax rose by $2,050 and the income rose by $10,000, the year was a good one. The refund is the wrong scoreboard.

A credit disappeared

Credits are the biggest single lever on a refund, and they vanish on birthdays. The Child Tax Credit is $2,200 per qualifying child under 17 for 2026. A child who turns 17 during the year no longer qualifies. The credit is gone, and the refund falls by the full $2,200, assuming there was tax to cut.

Take the family example on this site's estimator. A married couple on $110,000 with $8,000 of pre-tax contributions, $11,000 withheld, and two children gets a $7,520 refund. The tax before credits is $7,880, the credit cuts $4,400, and $3,480 remains. If the older child turns 17, the credit drops to $2,200, the tax after credits rises to $5,680, and the refund falls to $5,320. Same income, same withholding, same house, $2,200 less back. The only change is a birthday.

The phase-out works the same way in reverse. The credit shrinks by $50 for every $1,000 of adjusted gross income above $200,000 for a single filer and $400,000 for a married couple. A single filer at $210,000 with one child gets $1,700 instead of $2,200. Cross the threshold with a raise and the refund falls by $500 on top of the extra tax. The estimator applies the phase-out, so the number it returns already includes the cut.

Other credits move too. The Earned Income Tax Credit phases out as income rises, and it phases out fast: a few thousand dollars of extra income can cost more than a thousand dollars of credit. The education credits have their own income limits. If your refund fell and your income rose, check the credits first. They are usually the largest single line in the change.

Your withholding changed

The third reason is the W-4. A new job, a new W-4, or a mid-year adjustment changes how much is withheld from every paycheck, and the refund moves dollar for dollar with it. Withhold $1,000 more and the refund grows by $1,000. Withhold $1,000 less and it shrinks by $1,000. There is no mystery in it, and there is no tax change behind it.

Two common cases: a second job, and a bonus. A second job is withheld as if it were the only job, so the standard deduction is counted twice and the refund grows. Quit the second job and the refund shrinks back. A bonus is withheld at a flat 22 percent supplemental rate. If your marginal rate is 12 percent, the bonus is over-withheld by 10 points and the refund grows. If your marginal rate is 24 percent, the bonus is under-withheld and the refund shrinks. Neither case changes the tax owed. Both change the refund.

A new W-4 after marriage is the quietest version. The 2020 W-4 removed allowances and asks for dollar amounts instead. A filer who checked the box for a working spouse, or who entered a dollar amount for extra withholding, will see a smaller refund and larger paychecks. The money did not disappear. It arrived in the paychecks instead of the refund.

The standard deduction moved the other way

Not every change pushes the refund down. The 2026 standard deduction rose $350 for a single filer, to $16,100, and $700 for a married couple, to $32,200. At a 12 percent marginal rate, the $350 saves $42 of tax and adds $42 to the refund. The Child Tax Credit rose from $2,000 to $2,200, which adds $200 per child. The SALT cap rose from $10,000 to $40,000 for 2025, which helps itemizers in high-tax states. These are small pushes in the other direction, and they are worth knowing about, because they are the reason a refund can shrink by less than the withholding change alone would suggest.

How to check which one it is

Compare three lines year over year: the tax owed, the tax withheld, and the credits. The refund is the arithmetic of those three, and the change in the refund is the arithmetic of their changes. If the tax owed rose, the refund fell because the income or the brackets moved. If the withheld fell, the refund fell because the paychecks kept less. If the credits fell, the refund fell because a credit expired or phased out.

Run the estimator twice, once with last year's numbers and once with this year's. The difference between the two answers is the change, and the lines that moved are the reason. If the only change is the withholding, the refund fell by exactly the withholding change, and the year was fine. If the tax owed rose by more than the income, check the credits. If a child turned 17, the $2,200 is the answer, and there is nothing to fix.

The new insight

A smaller refund after a raise is usually good news wearing a bad costume. The $65,000 filer who becomes a $75,000 filer loses $2,050 of refund and gains $7,950 after tax. The refund fell because the tax rose by $2,050, and the tax rose because the income rose by $10,000. The scoreboard is the tax owed, not the refund. Anyone who compares refunds year over year is comparing the loan, not the income.

Sources: IRS Revenue Procedure 2025-32 (2026 brackets and standard deduction); IRS Filing Season Statistics, week ending December 26, 2025; TheStreet, March 2026 (2026 season average $3,521 as of March 27, peak $3,742 week ending February 20; IRS did not update 2025 withholding tables after the One Big Beautiful Bill Act; Tax Foundation $129 billion estimate; 44 percent of returns claimed a benefit); IRS Child Tax Credit page ($2,200 per child, phase-out $200,000 single and $400,000 joint). The scenario figures are this site’s Tax Refund Estimator unless stated otherwise.

Why Is My Tax Refund Smaller This Year? questions

Will my refund be smaller in 2027?
Probably, by about the size of the 2025 bump. The IRS did not update 2025 withholding tables after the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, so 2026 refunds came in about $350 fat on average. The 2026 tables are updated, so the same paycheck withholds less and the refund shrinks by the same amount.
Does a raise make my refund smaller?
Yes, by the extra tax on the raise. A single filer who goes from $65,000 to $75,000 with the same $6,500 withheld sees tax rise from $5,620 to $7,670, so the refund falls $2,050. The filer is still $7,950 better off after tax.
What if a child turned 17?
The Child Tax Credit is gone for that child: $2,200 less refund, assuming there was tax to cut. A married couple on $110,000 with two children gets $7,520 back; with one child aging out, the refund falls to $5,320.

Keep reading