Home › Bonus Tax Calculator › The Flat 22%: What 10,000 Bonus Scenarios Say

The bonus ledger · Data Study No. 7

The Flat 22%: What 10,000 Bonus Scenarios Say

The flat 22 percent is a guess. We ran 10,000 bonus scenarios through this site's own Bonus Tax Calculator to see how often the guess is wrong. It over-withholds in 61.4 percent of scenarios. The median over-withholding is $836.

The short answer

The flat 22 percent over-withholds in 61.4 percent of bonus scenarios. We ran 10,000 bonus scenarios through this site's own Bonus Tax Calculator, with salaries from $25,000 to $300,000 and bonuses from $500 to $30,000, and compared the flat withholding against the federal tax actually owed on each bonus. In 6,141 scenarios the flat rate took too much. The median over-withholding was $836. In 2,333 scenarios it took too little, with a median shortfall of $238. In 1,526 scenarios it landed within a dollar of the real tax. The pattern is a cliff, not a slope. Below $50,000 of salary, the flat rate over-withholds every time. Above $200,000, it never does.

This is the seventh weekly data study on this site. The method, the distributions, and the seed are stated below, so anyone can reproduce the numbers from the calculator on this site.

How the study ran

Each scenario drew a salary, a bonus, and a filing status, then ran the bonus through the calculator's federal engine: the flat 22 percent withholding on one side, and the tax on salary plus bonus minus the tax on salary alone on the other, using the 2026 brackets and standard deduction from IRS Revenue Procedure 2025-32. Social Security and Medicare were included in the share-kept figure but not in the over-withholding comparison, because the comparison is about the federal income tax line, and the payroll lines are final either way. No state tax was included, and no 401(k) deferral. The random draws used a seeded generator, seed 20261116, so the same 10,000 scenarios come out the same way every time the study is re-run.

The salary distribution was $25,000 to $300,000, skewed toward the lower end, because the workforce skews that way: the draw was 25,000 plus 275,000 times a uniform draw cubed, which puts the median salary near $59,000 and the mean near $94,000. The bonus distribution was $500 to $30,000, skewed the same way: 500 plus 29,500 times a uniform draw squared, which puts the median bonus near $7,900. Filing status was 55 percent single, 35 percent married filing jointly, and 10 percent head of household. The distributions are stated, not hidden, because the results depend on them. A study that drew only $200,000 salaries would find the opposite pattern, and the honest thing is to say so.

The headline numbers

OutcomeScenariosShareMedian size
Over-withheld (refund coming)6,14161.4%$836
Under-withheld (balance due)2,33323.3%$238
About right (within $1)1,52615.3%$0

Three numbers carry the story. The flat rate over-withholds more than twice as often as it under-withholds. The median over-withholding, $836, is more than three times the median shortfall, $238. And the median over-withholding is 10.3 percent of the bonus itself, which is the size of the bracket gap: the bonus sits in the 12 percent bracket while the withholding assumes 22 percent, and 10 points of a median bonus is about $836. The median share of the bonus kept after federal and payroll tax, 70.3 percent, matches the defaults case on the calculator, because the defaults sit in the middle of the distribution.

The cliff by salary band

Salary bandScenariosOver-withheldMedian over-withholding
Under $50,0004,568100.0%$968
$50,000 to $100,0001,99165.1%$590
$100,000 to $200,0002,08613.3%$593
Over $200,0001,3550.0%$0

The band table is the study in one view. Below $50,000 of salary, the bonus almost always sits in the 10 percent or 12 percent bracket, so the flat 22 percent over-withholds in every scenario, and the median over-withholding is $968, the largest of any band. Between $50,000 and $100,000, the bonus straddles the 12 percent and 22 percent brackets, so the flat rate over-withholds in 65.1 percent of scenarios and lands close in the rest. Between $100,000 and $200,000, the bonus mostly sits in the 22 percent bracket, so the flat rate is right most of the time and over-withholds in only 13.3 percent. Above $200,000, the bonus sits in the 24 percent bracket or higher, so the flat rate never over-withholds. It under-withholds instead.

The cliff is the mechanism. The brackets are steps, not a slope, so the flat rate is either above the bracket or below it, and the salary band decides which. A filer at $49,000 and a filer at $51,000 are nearly identical people, but their bonuses sit in different brackets, and the flat rate treats them the same. The $49,000 filer gets a refund. The $51,000 filer gets less of one. The $201,000 filer owes money. The salary is the only input that matters, and the flat rate is the only input that never looks at it.

What it means for a filer

The practical read is simple. If your salary is under $100,000, the flat 22 percent almost certainly over-withholds on your bonus, and the over-withholding is worth hundreds of dollars. The money comes back at filing, but it comes back months late, and it is your pay, not a windfall. The fix is the W-4: adjust the regular withholding down by the expected over-withholding, spread across the paychecks, and the money stays in the paychecks instead of the refund. If your salary is over $200,000, the flat rate under-withholds, and the shortfall is due at filing. The fix is the same W-4 in the other direction, or estimated payments, or a 401(k) deferral that cuts the taxable bonus before the withholding is figured.

The study also puts a number on the forced-saving argument. The median over-withheld filer lends the IRS $836 interest-free until filing season. At a 4 percent savings rate, six months of holding costs about $17 of interest. That is not a large amount, and for many filers the forced saving is worth more than $17. But it is a real cost, and it is the reason the calculator's verdict stamp reads OVER-WITHHELD instead of GOOD NEWS. The refund is the correction, not the reward.

What the study does not show

The study is about the federal income tax line only. It does not include state tax, which varies by state and can add a second over-withholding on top of the federal one. It does not include 401(k) deferrals, which cut the taxable bonus and shrink both the withholding and the tax. It does not include the aggregate withholding method, which matches the tax more closely and would shrink the over-withholding share. It does not include the Social Security wage base, which caps the payroll tax and raises the share kept for high earners. And it does not include the $1 million supplemental-wage line, because no scenario drew a bonus near it. The study is a picture of the flat rate against the brackets, for ordinary bonuses, and nothing else. The calculator on this site runs the full picture, including the lines the study leaves out.

The new insight

The flat 22 percent is not wrong by a little. It is wrong in one direction for most of the workforce, and the median error is $836. Below $50,000 of salary it over-withholds every time, and the median over-withholding is $968, which is more than the median bonus tax itself at that salary. The rate is a guess made for the employer's convenience, and the return is the only place the guess is corrected. The $836 is not a windfall. It is a loan, and the filer is the lender.

Sources: this site’s Bonus Tax Calculator (federal engine, 2026 brackets and standard deduction from IRS Revenue Procedure 2025-32); IRS Publication 15 (supplemental wages, flat 22 percent); Social Security Administration 2026 wage base $184,500. Method: 10,000 scenarios, seed 20261116, salary $25,000-$300,000 skewed low, bonus $500-$30,000 skewed low, 55% single / 35% married filing jointly / 10% head of household, federal income tax line only, no state tax, no deferral.

The Flat 22%: What 10,000 Bonus Scenarios Say questions

How was the study run?
10,000 scenarios, seed 20261116, through this site's own Bonus Tax Calculator. Salary $25,000 to $300,000 skewed low, bonus $500 to $30,000 skewed low, 55 percent single, 35 percent married filing jointly, 10 percent head of household. Federal income tax line only, no state tax, no deferral. The seed makes the same 10,000 scenarios reproducible.
Who gets over-withheld the most?
Filers under $50,000 of salary. The flat rate over-withheld in 100.0 percent of those scenarios, with a median over-withholding of $968. Between $50,000 and $100,000 it over-withheld in 65.1 percent. Above $200,000 it never over-withheld.
What should I do with the result?
If your salary is under $100,000, expect a refund on the bonus and consider adjusting your W-4 so the money stays in your paychecks. If it is over $200,000, expect a balance due and adjust the other way, or defer part of the bonus to a 401(k).

Keep reading