Home › Bonus Tax Calculator › How to Keep More of Your Bonus

The bonus ledger · Table No. 59

How to Keep More of Your Bonus

Three levers keep more of a bonus: the 401(k) deferral, the calendar, and the W-4. None of them make the bonus tax-free. The work is moving the money to the year and the account where it is taxed least.

The short answer

There are three levers that keep more of a bonus, and they work in different directions. Defer part of the bonus to a 401(k) and the federal withholding falls by the marginal rate times the deferral. Time the bonus across the year-end line and it is taxed in the lower year. Fix the W-4 and the over-withholding comes back in the paychecks instead of the refund. None of them change the tax you owe by more than the marginal rate times the amount moved, and none of them make the bonus tax-free. The work is moving the money to the year and the account where it is taxed least.

This article covers the 401(k) lever, the calendar lever, and the W-4 lever, in that order, and the moves that do not work last.

The 401(k) lever

The 401(k) lever is the only one that cuts the tax itself. A deferral comes out before income tax is figured, so it shrinks the taxable bonus. Defer 10 percent of a $10,000 bonus and $1,000 goes to the retirement account. The taxable bonus becomes $9,000, and the federal withholding at 22 percent falls from $2,200 to $1,980. That is $220 saved. Defer 20 percent and $2,000 goes to the account, the taxable bonus becomes $8,000, and the federal withholding falls to $1,760, a $440 saving. The net on the check falls too, from $7,035 to $6,255 at 10 percent and to $5,475 at 20 percent, but the drop is mostly retirement savings, not tax. At 10 percent, $780 of the drop is the $1,000 deferral minus the $220 tax saving. The $1,000 is still yours, in the account, growing tax-deferred.

The catch is payroll tax. Social Security and Medicare still apply to the full bonus, because 401(k) deferrals are not exempt from payroll tax. The $620 of Social Security and $145 of Medicare on a $10,000 bonus do not change when the deferral changes. The deferral also has to be set up before the bonus is paid. An election made after the check is cut does not change the withholding on it. Most plans let you change the deferral percentage per paycheck, so a one-time bump for the bonus pay period is the practical move: raise the percentage for the bonus check, then put it back.

The 2026 401(k) limit is $24,500 for employee deferrals, with a $8,000 catch-up for filers 50 and older. A bonus deferral counts against that limit, so a filer who is already maxing out has no room left. The limit is the ceiling. The deferral is the lever, and it only works below the ceiling.

The calendar lever

The calendar lever moves the bonus to the year where it is taxed least. A bonus paid in December counts in this tax year. A bonus paid in January counts in the next one. The difference matters when the two years have different brackets. A filer who is retiring in January, taking a sabbatical, or expecting a lower-income year next year should ask for the January date, because the bonus will be taxed at the lower bracket. A filer who expects a raise in January should ask for the December date, because the bonus will be taxed at this year's lower bracket instead of next year's higher one.

The lever is small for most people. A $10,000 bonus moving from the 22 percent bracket to the 12 percent bracket saves $1,000. Moving from the 24 percent bracket to the 22 percent bracket saves $200. The lever is worth the most at a bracket edge, and it is worth nothing when both years are in the same bracket. The employer has to agree to the date, and many will not, because the bonus is accrued in one year and paid in the next for accounting reasons. Ask, and take the answer. The lever is free to try.

The calendar lever has a second edge. The $1 million supplemental-wage line is per calendar year, per employer. A $1.2 million bonus paid in one year has $200,000 withheld at 37 percent. The same bonus split across two calendar years, $600,000 in each, is withheld at 22 percent on the whole amount. The saving is $30,000 of withholding, and the tax itself is the same, because the brackets are annual. The split changes the withholding, not the tax. The return reconciles it either way.

The W-4 lever

The W-4 lever does not change the tax. It changes when the money arrives. The flat 22 percent over-withholds for everyone whose marginal bracket is below 22 percent. A single filer on $40,000 with a $5,000 bonus is over-withheld by $500 every year the bonus is paid. The $500 comes back as a refund in the spring. The W-4 adjustment keeps the $500 in the paychecks instead. The IRS Tax Withholding Estimator is free, on irs.gov, and it walks through income, withholding, and credits, then tells you exactly what to put on the W-4. It takes about fifteen minutes with a pay stub and last year's return in hand.

On the defaults on this site's calculator, the $5,000 bonus has $1,482.50 withheld and nets $3,517.50. The $1,100 federal line is the one the W-4 touches. A filer in the 12 percent bracket who is over-withheld by $500 can add $500 of annual withholding reduction to the W-4, spread across the paychecks, and the bonus withholding stays the same while the regular withholding falls. The refund shrinks by $500 and the paychecks grow by the same amount. The money is the same. The timing is the preference.

The right target is close to even: a refund or balance due under $100, so the money stays in the paychecks and the April surprise is small. The calculator's verdict stamp reads WITHHELD ABOUT RIGHT when the flat withholding lands within $100 of the tax actually owed. That is the band to aim for. It takes one W-4 adjustment and one pay cycle to get there.

What not to do

Do not ask for the bonus as stock or options to avoid the tax. Restricted stock and options are taxed as supplemental wages when they vest or are exercised, at the same rates, with the same withholding. The form changes. The tax does not. Do not ask to be paid as a contractor for the bonus. A contractor payment is self-employment income, which adds 15.3 percent self-employment tax on top of the income tax, and the employer will not do it anyway, because the classification rules are strict and the penalties are real.

Do not over-withhold on purpose as a savings plan. It is a savings plan that pays zero interest, holds the money for an average of six months, and returns it in a lump sum that feels like a windfall. The $500 over-withholding on a $5,000 bonus at a $40,000 salary is $41.67 a month that could have been in the paycheck. A savings account at 4 percent pays about $10 of interest on it over six months. That is not a fortune, but it is free money, and the W-4 adjustment that captures it takes fifteen minutes.

Do not spend the gross. The most common bonus mistake is budgeting the $10,000 and spending $10,000, then finding $7,035 in the bank. The net is the number to plan around, and the calculator on this site prints it. Budget the net. Save the refund if one is coming. Pay the balance due if one is owed. The bonus is $7,035 of money, not $10,000 of money, and the plan that knows that is the plan that works.

The new insight

The cheapest way to keep more of a bonus is to change nothing and file the return. A single filer on $40,000 with a $5,000 bonus is owed $500 back, because the flat 22 percent took $1,100 and the tax is $600. The refund is not something to earn. It is something to collect. The levers move the timing and the account, not the tax, and the return is the only place the over-withholding is corrected.

Sources: IRS Publication 15 (supplemental wages, flat 22 percent); IRS Tax Withholding Estimator (irs.gov); IRS Revenue Procedure 2025-32 (2026 brackets and standard deduction); IRS Notice 2025-67 (2026 401(k) deferral limit $24,500, catch-up $8,000). The scenario figures are this site’s Bonus Tax Calculator unless stated otherwise.

How to Keep More of Your Bonus questions

How much does a 401(k) deferral save on a bonus?
$220 on a $10,000 bonus at 10 percent deferral. The deferral cuts the taxable bonus to $9,000, so federal withholding falls from $2,200 to $1,980. Social Security and Medicare still apply to the full $10,000, because 401(k) deferrals are not exempt from payroll tax.
Should I take my bonus in December or January?
Take it in the lower-income year. A December bonus counts in this tax year, and a January bonus counts in the next one. Moving a $10,000 bonus from the 22 percent bracket to the 12 percent bracket saves $1,000. The employer has to agree to the date.
What is the 401(k) limit for 2026?
$24,500 for employee deferrals, with an $8,000 catch-up for filers 50 and older, per IRS Notice 2025-67. A bonus deferral counts against that limit, so a filer who is already maxing out has no room left.

Keep reading