Home › Bonus Tax Calculator › Why Is My Bonus Taxed So Much?

The bonus ledger · Table No. 59

Why Is My Bonus Taxed So Much?

A $5,000 bonus nets $3,517.50 because three taxes come out at once, and the biggest is a flat rate that ignores your bracket. The tax you actually owe is lower for most filers, and the gap comes back at filing.

The short answer

Your bonus looks heavily taxed because three different taxes come out at once, and the biggest one is a flat rate that ignores your bracket. Federal withholding is 22 percent. Social Security is 6.2 percent. Medicare is 1.45 percent. Together they take 29.65 percent of the bonus before state tax, so a $5,000 bonus nets $3,517.50 and a $10,000 bonus nets $7,035. The shock is real, and the number is also misleading. The 22 percent is withholding, not the tax rate. The tax you actually owe is figured on your return, and for most filers it is lower than 22 percent, which means part of the withholding comes back.

This article separates the three lines, explains why the flat rate exists, and shows who gets money back and who owes more.

Three taxes, one check

The first reason a bonus looks heavily taxed is that the pay stub shows three taxes at once. A regular paycheck spreads the same taxes across the year, so no single check looks dramatic. A bonus compresses them into one line. The federal line is $1,100 on a $5,000 bonus. The Social Security line is $310. The Medicare line is $72.50. The total is $1,482.50, which is 29.65 percent of the bonus. Nothing about the bonus is taxed at a special higher rate. It is taxed as ordinary income, exactly like salary. The difference is that salary is taxed a little at a time, and the bonus is taxed all at once.

State tax is the fourth line, and it is the one that varies. California withholds 10.23 percent on bonuses, which takes another $511.50 out of a $5,000 bonus and leaves $3,006. At a 5 percent state rate the same bonus nets $3,267.50. In the nine states with no income tax, the three federal lines are the whole story. If your bonus looks worse than the 29.65 percent, the state line is usually the reason.

Why 22 percent

The 22 percent comes from IRS Publication 15, and it is a choice the employer makes, not a rate the law sets on your income. Bonuses are supplemental wages. The normal withholding tables assume a steady paycheck, and a bonus breaks that assumption, so the IRS lets employers use a flat rate instead. The flat rate is 22 percent on the first $1 million of supplemental wages in a calendar year, and 37 percent above that. The employer picks the flat rate because it is simple and because it protects the employer from under-withholding penalties. The employer has no incentive to match your bracket. Matching your bracket is your return's job.

The flat rate has been 22 percent every year since 2018. It is not a new tax, and it is not a penalty for getting a bonus. It is the same rate the IRS has used for supplemental wages for eight years, and it stays 22 percent for 2026. The individual income tax rates were made permanent in 2025, so the 22 percent is not scheduled to change in 2027 either. What changes is your bracket, not the withholding rate.

Withholding is not the tax

The most important sentence in bonus tax is this: withholding is a prepayment, not the final tax. Your employer sends 22 percent to the IRS as a deposit against the tax you will owe. Your return figures the real tax at the end of the year, using the brackets, the standard deduction, and your total income from every source. If the deposit is larger than the tax, the difference comes back as a refund. If it is smaller, the difference is due.

The gap runs in both directions, and the direction depends on your salary. A single filer on $40,000 with a $5,000 bonus owes $600 of federal tax on the bonus, because the bonus sits in the 12 percent bracket. The employer withheld $1,100. The $500 gap comes back. A single filer on $50,000 with the same bonus owes $600 as well, because the bonus still sits in the 12 percent bracket, and the same $500 comes back. A married couple on $100,000 with a $10,000 bonus owes $1,200, because the bonus sits in the 12 percent bracket for joint filers, and $1,000 comes back. The flat rate over-withholds for everyone whose marginal bracket is below 22 percent, which is most of the workforce.

The other direction is rarer and more expensive. A single filer on $300,000 with a $10,000 bonus owes $3,500, because the bonus sits in the 35 percent bracket. The employer withheld $2,200. The $1,300 gap is due at filing. A filer on $250,000 with a $10,000 bonus owes $3,200, because the bonus sits in the 32 percent bracket, and $1,000 is due. A filer on $180,000 with a $10,000 bonus owes $2,400, because the bonus sits in the 24 percent bracket, and $200 is due. The flat rate under-withholds for everyone whose marginal bracket is above 22 percent, and the gap grows with the bracket.

The aggregate method, and why you probably do not get it

The employer has a second choice, and it fixes most of the gap. Under the aggregate method, the bonus is added to the regular paycheck, withholding is computed on the combined amount with the normal brackets and the W-4 elections, and the withholding that would have applied to the salary alone is subtracted. The result is the tax on the bonus, figured the same way the return figures it. At a $40,000 salary the aggregate method withholds $600 on a $5,000 bonus, not $1,100. At a $300,000 salary it withholds $3,500 on a $10,000 bonus, not $2,200. The refund and the balance due both disappear.

Most employers do not use it. The flat rate is one multiplication. The aggregate method requires the payroll system to run the bracket math on a combined check, which is more work and more room for error. The choice belongs to the employer, and the employee cannot ask for the other method. If your bonus is withheld at 22 percent, that is the method your employer picked, and the return is the only correction.

When the bonus is combined with regular pay

There is one case where the withholding can look even higher than 22 percent. If your employer adds the bonus to a regular paycheck instead of paying it separately, the aggregate method applies, and the withholding is computed as if you earned that much every pay period. A $5,000 bonus added to a $3,000 biweekly paycheck is withheld as if the annual salary were $208,000, which pushes the combined check into the 24 percent and 32 percent brackets for withholding purposes. The federal withholding on that check can exceed 22 percent of the bonus, sometimes by a lot. It is still only withholding. The return figures the real tax on the annual total, and the excess comes back. But the check looks worse than the flat-rate check, and the surprise is the reason this article exists.

The reverse case is the second job. A second job is withheld as if it were the only job, so the standard deduction is counted twice and the refund grows. A bonus from a second employer is withheld at 22 percent regardless of what the first employer paid. The two employers do not coordinate. Only the return sees the whole year.

The payroll tax lines do not come back

One part of the withholding is final. Social Security and Medicare are payroll taxes, not income tax, and they are not reconciled on the return. The $310 of Social Security and $72.50 of Medicare on a $5,000 bonus are gone, and no refund brings them back. The only exception is the wage base. If your total wages for the year cross $184,500, Social Security stops, and any Social Security withheld after the base is crossed is refunded on the return. The additional 0.9 percent Medicare is also reconciled: the employer withholds it above $200,000 of wages, but the tax is owed above $200,000 for single filers and $250,000 for married couples, so a married couple can get the slice between $200,000 and $250,000 back. The federal income tax line is the one that moves. The payroll lines are the price of the bonus, every time.

What to do about it

There are three moves, and only one of them changes the tax. Defer part of the bonus to a 401(k) before it is paid, and the federal withholding falls by the marginal rate times the deferral. Defer 10 percent of a $10,000 bonus and the federal line falls by $220. The $1,000 goes to retirement instead of the paycheck. The payroll lines do not change, because 401(k) deferrals are not exempt from payroll tax. The second move is timing. A bonus paid in December counts in this tax year. A bonus paid in January counts in the next one. If this year is a high-income year and next year will be lower, the January bonus is taxed at the lower bracket. The third move is the W-4. If the flat rate over-withholds every year, adjust the W-4 to keep the money in the paychecks instead of lending it to the IRS until April. The refund is not free money. It is your pay, returned late.

The new insight

The bonus is not taxed at 22 percent. It is withheld at 22 percent. The tax is 12 percent for a single filer on $40,000, 22 percent on $75,000, and 35 percent on $300,000, all on the same $10,000 bonus. The paycheck shows the withholding. The return shows the tax. The difference is $1,000 back, nothing, or $1,300 due, and the salary is the only thing that decides which one you get.

Sources: IRS Publication 15 (supplemental wages, flat 22 percent, aggregate method); IRS Topic No. 751; wagewiseo Bonus Tax Calculator 2026 (withholding is not the tax; additional 0.9 percent Medicare over $200,000); getmoneymeter Bonus Tax Calculator 2026 (flat rate 22 percent every year since 2018; 2027 expected to stay 22 percent); Social Security Administration 2026 wage base $184,500; IRS Revenue Procedure 2025-32 (2026 brackets and standard deduction). The scenario figures are this site’s Bonus Tax Calculator unless stated otherwise.

Why Is My Bonus Taxed So Much? questions

Is my bonus taxed at a higher rate than my salary?
No. A bonus is taxed as ordinary income, exactly like salary. It looks heavily taxed because the federal, Social Security, and Medicare lines all come out of one check, and the federal line is a flat 22 percent that ignores your bracket. The tax you actually owe is figured on your return, using the brackets.
How long has the bonus tax rate been 22 percent?
Every year since 2018. The flat supplemental-wage withholding rate is 22 percent on the first $1 million of supplemental wages in a calendar year, and 37 percent above that. The individual income tax rates were made permanent in 2025, so the rate is expected to stay 22 percent in 2027.
Can I ask my employer to withhold less on my bonus?
Not directly. The employer picks the withholding method, flat or aggregate, and the employee does not get a vote. What you can do is adjust your W-4 so the regular paychecks withhold less, which offsets the over-withholding on the bonus over the year.

Keep reading